The lower cutoffs answer a real biological pattern rather than a rounding preference. Asian Indians tend to carry more body fat at any given BMI than white Europeans do. More of this fat is stored deep in the abdomen. That is the thin outside, fat inside phenotype. It means a person can look slim and sit inside the normal BMI band but still carry a metabolic risk profile closer to someone the chart would call overweight.
Consider a real-world example of this phenotype in action. A 40-year-old Indian man might maintain a consistent weight and a BMI of 24. While a standard global calculator calls him healthy, his waist measures 92 cm. This places him in the abdominal obesity category according to Indian guidelines. This explains why his recent blood tests might reveal elevated fasting sugar or high triglycerides despite his supposedly normal weight.
Indian cohort data made the case for these lower numbers. A Delhi cohort study of non-obese adults with a BMI under 25 found that most already carried at least one cardiovascular risk factor. That risk rose steeply within the range Western charts treat as safe. Findings like these are why researchers argued the normal ranges needed revising for Asian Indians.
The international bodies moved more cautiously. The 2004 WHO expert consultation reviewed the evidence that Asian populations face higher diabetes and heart risk at lower BMI levels. They declined to set separate Asian cutoffs and kept 25 and 30 as global classifications. Instead, they flagged 23, 27.5, 32.5, and 37.5 kg/m² as public health action points that individual countries could adopt. India took the 23 point and built its own thresholds on top of it.